Why do our brains choose present pleasure over future happiness? Understanding this secret reveals the path to preparing for retirement.
- The fundamental psychological reasons for failing to save for retirement
- Why behavioral economics’ ’nudge’ and ‘default option’ are powerful solutions
- The critical differences between successful overseas retirement pension systems and the Korean model
Why do we fail to save? A diagnosis from behavioral economics
Within our minds coexist the wise ‘planner’ who plans for the future and the impulsive ‘doer’ who enjoys the present. Unfortunately, in most battles, the winner is the ‘doer.’ Behavioral economics’ default option is a powerful system that helps the planner win in this inner conflict. I too often promise myself on payday, ‘This month, I will definitely save,’ but I have repeatedly succumbed to the temptation of the ‘doer’ clicking the payment button for new sneakers.
This is not a matter of willpower but rather due to several biases deeply ingrained in our brains.
These are psychological biases that make immediate pleasures feel more significant than vague future happiness.
Present Bias: The Importance of Now Over the Future
Our brains react much more strongly to ‘100,000 won today’ than to ‘1 million won in a year.’ The gravitational pull of immediate small pleasures is so strong that it makes us chant, ‘I’ll start saving next month’ like a mantra.
Loss Aversion: The Pain of Loss Greater Than the Joy of Gain
People psychologically feel the pain of losing 100,000 won twice as intensely as the joy of gaining 100,000 won. Transferring salary to a savings account is perceived as a ’loss’ because it reduces the money available for immediate use. This immediate pain of loss is much greater than the uncertain future benefits, leading to hesitation in saving.
Status Quo Bias: The Trap of ‘Doing Things as Usual’
Ultimately, this psychological conflict often leads to the conclusion, ‘Oh, I don’t know. Let’s just live as we are.’ Without a special trigger, we have a strong inertia to maintain the existing state. The current state of ’not saving’ is so comfortable, like a cozy sofa, that once we sit down, it’s hard to get up.
The Key to Solving the Problem: Nudge and Default Option
So, what is the solution? Behavioral economists suggest ‘choice architecture’ that exploits human irrationality instead of blaming willpower. Among these, the most powerful tools are nudge and default option.
- Nudge: Meaning ’to gently poke with an elbow,’ it is a soft intervention that guides behavior in a desirable direction without coercion.
- Default Option: The most powerful among numerous nudge strategies, it refers to the ‘default setting that is automatically applied when nothing is chosen.’
The default option turns the ‘doer’s’ strongest weapons, ‘inertia’ and ‘status quo bias,’ into our allies. A representative example is the stark difference in organ donation consent rates between Germany (12% opt-in) and Austria (99% opt-out).
Successful Overseas Default Option Cases
The United States, the United Kingdom, and Australia have successfully applied these insights from behavioral economics to their retirement pension systems. The key for all of them is the ‘opt-out’ method.
United States: Save More Tomorrow (SMarT)
In 2006, when companies were allowed to automatically enroll employees in retirement plans (401(k)), participation rates soared from below 50% to over 90%. Additionally, the SMarT program designed by Richard Thaler automatically increases the savings rate in line with salary increases, raising participants’ average savings rate from 3.5% to over 11.6% in just three years.
United Kingdom: Mandatory Automatic Enrollment, NEST
Since 2012, all companies have been required to automatically enroll employees in the state-led pension scheme (NEST). As a result, workplace pension enrollment rates surged from 55% to over 78%, with withdrawal rates remaining around 8%.
Australia: Growth-Oriented MySuper
Employers are required to contribute 11% of wages, and if employees do not provide specific investment instructions, their funds are automatically invested in a growth-oriented portfolio (MySuper), which has a stock allocation of 60-75%. This reflects the philosophy that pursuing high returns is more beneficial for workers in the long term.
What’s Wrong with the Korean Default Option?
In 2022, Korea introduced a default option called the ‘pre-designated management system.’ However, it faces criticism for being a ‘facade of a default option’ that misses the core of successful overseas cases.
The Korean model has a fatal flaw in that it fails to leverage the human nature of ’not wanting to do anything.’
The biggest problem is that subscribers must actively choose one from a list of products in an ‘opt-in’ manner. If they give up on making a choice, their money remains in cash assets as before. As a result, about 89% of total accumulated funds are concentrated in ‘ultra-low-risk’ products, which is the opposite of the intended purpose of the system.
A Quick Comparison of Systems: Overseas vs. Korea
| Category | Successful Overseas Cases (Opt-out) | Korean Pre-Designated Management System (Opt-in) |
|---|---|---|
| Enrollment Method | Automatic enrollment and automatic investment as the default | Subscribers must actively select products to operate |
| Core Principle | Utilizes ‘inertia’ and ‘status quo bias’ for saving | Requires active behavior and financial understanding from subscribers |
| Key Results | High enrollment rates, automatic increases, improved long-term returns | Concentration in ultra-low-risk products, dilution of system purpose |
Self-Nudge Checklist for the Planner
While waiting for the system to change, we can set ‘good defaults’ in our lives ourselves. What safety measures have you prepared for your future self?
- ✅ Set up automatic transfers on payday: Ensure that money is transferred to savings/investment accounts without room for hesitation.
- ✅ Apply for automatic increase services: Make sure that your savings/investment amount increases automatically whenever your salary rises. (Related article: How to Start a Pension Savings Fund)
- ✅ Check your pension account portfolio: Ensure that your precious retirement funds are not sleeping in cash assets and consider adjusting to growth-oriented assets.
- ✅ Open the investment app before the credit card app: Place the investment app on your smartphone’s home screen to shift the impulse of the ‘doer’ to the attention of the ‘planner.’
Conclusion: The Wisdom to Change the Future Through Action
Our failure to prepare for retirement is not a matter of individual willpower. Behavioral economics has shown that the cause lies in predictable psychological biases, and it offers hope that we can overcome them through wise system design.
-
Key Summary
- Failing to save is not due to a lack of will but the battle between the inner ‘planner’ and ‘doer.’
- Powerful ‘default options’ like automatic enrollment and automatic increases guide our inertia in beneficial directions.
- True ‘opt-out’ design is the key challenge to improving the returns of Korea’s retirement pension system.
Check your retirement pension account now and set a ‘good default’ for your future self. A small action can change your life in 30 years.
References
- Dual-Self Model - The Decision Lab
- Cognitive Bias - Wikipedia
- Save More Tomorrow™: Using Behavioral Economics to Increase Employee Saving - Journal of Political Economy
- The Invisible Powerful Hand ‘Default Option’ - KSAM Magazine
- The Planning Self and the Acting Self - Incheon News
- An Economic Theory of Self-Control - Journal of Political Economy
- The Role of Behavioral Economics and Behavioral Decision Making in Americans’ Retirement Savings Decisions - SSA
- Behavioral Economics - Namu Wiki
- Nudge - Kyobo Bookstore
- AVR Impact on State Voter Registration - Brennan Center for Justice
- Pension Protection Act of 2006: Automatic Enrollment - Bradley Arant Boult Cummings LLP
- National Employment Savings Trust Corporation annual report and accounts - GOV.UK
- The Secret to Australia’s Successful Retirement Pension is ‘Mandatory Default Options’ - Korea Financial News
- Current Status and Supplementary Tasks After the Introduction of the Pre-Designated Management System for Retirement Pensions - National Assembly Legislative Research Service
- Most are in savings accounts, but a 10% return?… Controversy over the distortion of default option performance - Daum
- (Refer to the original input for the complete list of sources)